Injector Pump, Tranny

New ‘IDI-Online’ C6 VRV (Vacuum Regulator Valve) Progress.

Since the IDI C6 VRV (Vacuum Regulator Valve) was discontinued years ago, they are becoming scarcer and scarcer.  I’ve been working on developing a new IDI-Online VRV based on the old design for the 6.9 and 7.3 IDI, but with a few enhancements to make the part simpler and easier to maintain.

The older VRV is plastic and eventually breaks down.  Since there are no replacement parts for sale, this leaves the IDI owner with a tough decision: either replace the transmission with the inferior E4OD or scrap the vehicle.  My goal is provide a new VRV that takes the place of the older part.

I’ve been waiting to announce this for a few weeks because it required a lot of research to document everything, but I’m getting to the point where I feel I’m only a few weeks away from having a functioning prototype.

Ultimately, when this is done, I’m going to provide two types of products.  First, I’m going to develop an inventory of replacement cams, cam links, covers, and parts for the existing VRV.  Next, I’m going to provide finished product VRV’s, that are custom designed by me to eliminate some of the unnecessary components that either wear early, breakdown, or really don’t need to be included on the VRV for the IDI IP.  I’m hoping to have functioning prototypes soon, and if all goes well, new IDI-Online VRV’s for sale by the end of summer.

If all goes well, I might develop an aluminum VRV, that should last substantially longer than any plastic part.

I’ll continue to post more information on my progress as things develop.  I hope to have the first round of prototypes mailed to me in a few weeks.

Update: 6/14/2018:

I got all the stock parts modeled and prepped.  It was a lot of work.  I’m pretty happy with the detail I was able to model, including all the weep holes, notches, ports, etc.  I was even able to get the housing completely designed in 3D, which was probably the most complex solid-model that I even built.

Using assembly design, I was able to virtually-test the model and its action.  Everything pretty much worked out, except the castle nut and cam housing cover.  I used the 3D clash detection to make sure everything fit just right, and made adjustments accordingly.

So far so good.  After testing various mesh resolutions, I found a good balance of file-size and mesh detail.  Checked it in another program before sending the files off for prototyping.

I chose three different types of plastic for the testing phase of this project.  I’m going to make these in what-they-call “Professional Plastic.”  They claim the nylon plastic is good up to 350 deg F, watertight, tensile strength (up to 6960 psi), and chemically resistant (to oils, greases, allphatic hydrocarbons, and alkalies).  Ideally, I need these VRV Parts to be high-temp rated and have good abrasion resistance, but I ordered two other types of plastic that I’m pretty confident won’t work.  I’ve done quite a bit of prototyping, and the cheaper plastics won’t hold up in an engine bay.  But regardless, I ordered them just to see how they compare to the professional-style plastic prototypes.  I’ll post images once they arrive.

 

If the prototypes work out, I’ll order a bulk shipment and begin the first phase of this VRV project.  I’ll set up a store selling replacement parts for the VRV, like new cams, cam-links, housings, etc.  Then I’ll work on new diaphragms for the VRV.  Also, I’m doing some legwork for finding decent spring replacements.  And ultimately, I want to get to work on my custom VRV design.

 

Update 6/17/18:

I’ve been working with another plastics supplier to figure out an alternative for the diaphragm setup on the stock VRV.  We’ve narrowed it down to two types of plastics/resins, and we are developing a strategy to prototype an array of thicknesses to optimized the flexibility where it counts.  Also, there are other factors in the prototyping process that make this really difficult to produce; like flexibility, durability, longevity, and rigidity.  The sales rep and engineer at my supplier have been instrumental in making sure I can model up something that will suit my needs for the VRV.

I’ll keep on moving forward.  This diaphragm resin is pretty expensive (along with the other prototype plastics), but I’m willing to make the investment to make sure I get a diaphragm that is the precise thickness to ensure 5 in-hg to 13 in-hg as per the service manual specifications.

Onward.

 

Update 6/19/18:

The first round of diaphragm 3D models got approved, so I progressed with modeling an array of various dimension and shape diaphragms for prototyping.

Also, I’m still debating on how to connect the diaphragm to the camlink.  I’m testing springs and different elastic plastics.  I’ve been talking to a large spring manufacturer in the hopes they have something VERY similar to the stock spring already exists in their inventory.  Maybe with a bulk purchase, I can make this assembly somewhat affordable.

With the latest prototyping processes, I can make pretty much any amalgamation I can think of.  So to simplify the whole component, I’d like to explore concepts that reduce the overall count of parts in the VRV.  Less parts usually means less possibility for failure.

Once I get more of the prototypes, I’ll learn more of capabilities of the plastics, and then I’ll keep progressing on IDI-Online version of the VRV.

 

Update:

The latest set of prototypes is “in production.”  I snapped some photos of the facility’s mesh reading software….

Looking good!  They estimate delivery of the rigid plastic prototypes around June 29.

Still no word back from the diaphragm plastic cost estimates yet.  Their facility is a little smaller so I’m cutting them some slack.  I run my own business and know how hard it can be to keep a balance of work-and-life.  I’m hoping for the estimates any day now.

Onward!

Update 6/20/18:

Some bad news.  The diaphragm 3D model didn’t pass the more advanced examination.  Something about the connection material was too small for the resolution of the printer.  I’m not really sure how to resolve this yet, I’m brainstorming a new solution.  I don’t have a lot of options, because the diaphragm diameter is really small, so extending it will mean creating a larger footprint, thus reducing the flexing capacity of the diaphragm plastic.  Back to the drawing board.

As for the spring manufacturers, I’ve been going back and forth on that whole ordeal.  We have tried to get some early cost estimation, but since the springs are so odd, they don’t have a good number yet.  I’m currently at the point of modeling up the current springs and producing some drawings to aide their bidding.

Some set backs, but I’m going to keep moving forward.   The first quote for the springs came out to $400-500 per spring.  LOL.

I’ve been trying to make sure that all my products are American Made.  So I’m shopping around for more spring manufacturers anywhere in the 50 states.  Any suggestions, leave a comment below.

 

Update 6/22/18

I’ve made the latest revisions to the diaphragm prototypes and sent them off for approvals.  I have four different designs (2-way flat disc, 4-way flat disc, 2-way domed-disc, and wide slot flat disc).  I’m still confounded on why the last two prototype meshes were rejected, and their explanation was really enigmatic.  If they reject this latest design, then I’m going to have to talk directly with their production team, because the sales staff is giving me the run around.  Also, I might have to move toward building my own metal mold and pouring my own diaphragm plastics/resins…. Until then here are some pictures:

Update 7/4/18

The first round of prototype plastics arrived!

I’ll start testing the plastics for their longevity, durability, etc.

 

 

Update July 20, 2018

Got the diaphragm prototypes.  Lots of issues.  Those parts will require a full redesign, with the orientations revised.

 

Update August 3, 2018:

I’ve done an early assessment of the prototypes, and there are issues.  I need to revise the 3D models and send out for a 2nd batch of plastics to make sure the proper tolerances are met.  Some of the 3D printers must have varying printing tolerances that are affecting the sizing of these meshes, but overall, I’m pretty pleased with the output.  Maybe a less fastidious designer would accept the models as is, but I want to make sure they fit together perfectly, and that means more prototyping.  I’m quite sure this means I won’t have anything ready for sale by the end of August, but Autumn 2018 is definitely in play.

The first round of plastics were considered “Professional” plastics, with supposedly quite good heat, vibration, and tensile resistant properties.  If the product ever went up for sale, I would insist I use this material, because structurally, it is supposedly the best of all the printable plastics I could find.  The only downside to this material is the graininess.  The material comes in grey and black, and in the future, I’ll just stick with the black.  The grey looks really speckled and odd.  I’m not really impressed with that variation.

With respect to mating tolerances, the castle nut and VRV Cap models appeared to have printed perfectly, thus allowing for a great fitting.

With the castle+cap combined, the top housing threaded on with ease.  One issue here was the tolerance on the threads.  It made the cap wobble a bit, but knowing my stock VRV, the cap wobbles on that too.  I think I’ll adjust the 3D offset tolerance on that in my parametric 3D model when I send for the second round of prototypes.

Unfortunately, the cam seems slightly off with this particular printed plastic.  I would like that to fit a little better and more snug, rather than the slop that is visually apparent in the previous photo.

Also, the Cam Cover fit well, but it appeared to be too thick.  Or maybe the receiving-groove in the main housing wasn’t deep enough.  Regardless, if I revise that, the top surfaces would be slightly more flush.  Not a big deal, just had to mark down in my notes for revising the 3D Parametric model.

The second type of plastic I tested was the white “processed” plastic.  This too had a good deal of graininess that I really didn’t want to see.  I’m worried this kind of abrasiveness would inhibit good cam and cam-link movement and possibly induce premature wear on the system.  I don’t know until I conduct extensive materials testing.

At least with the processed plastic type, the tolerances seemed to fit better.  The cam sizing was perfect, so that wouldn’t require any additional prototyping remodeling.  Also, the rotation of the cam with the cam-link was smoother.  I guess with proper lubrication, the abrasiveness of the printed plastics might not be an issue.  In fact, it might help the grease cling to the pockets in the plastic, thus allowing for a better lubricity and retention of parts.  Just speculation at this point.  I’m still hesitant to lube this up until I get better diaphragm prototypes (see below) and some company to accept my drawings for spring production.

With the white plastic, the cam-link BARELY fit in the housing grooves.  The black plastic was actually QUITE sloppy, so that’s one of the differences with the two plastic printing types.  The tolerances might be off by as much as 1/64″ which is kind of unacceptable.  I need this to be good down to at least 0.005″ if this is going to reproduceable and viable for sales.

Just like the black and grey castle-cap assy, the white parts fit perfectly and snuggly spun.  Also, the white cap fit on the cruciform of the main housing snuggly, so it didn’t wobble.  I liked it a lot better.  No need to adjust the threads on this plastic.

Sadly, the white VRV cap didn’t have a proper vacuum port.  The plastic must have gotten stuck in the hole when they pulled it from the bed.  Bummer.  Looks like Professional Plastic is the only way to go for the cap.

I also invested in the cheaper clear plastic as well.  It appears to be far superior to the other two plastics in terms of smoothness.  It is really spiffy, but it doesn’t have much for heat and strength resistance.  I gave it a shot anyway just to try it out.

One thing that was kind of cool was the ability to see the cam and cam-link thru the transparent plastic.

 

Sadly, as I was simply trying to push the clear plastic castle on the cap, it broke rather easily.  I basically handled this part for less than 5 seconds before it broke.  I think this confirms that the clear plastic cannot be trusted on this project.

My diaphragm connector testing went well.  The closest plastic to match the elasticity of the stock spring is the second and third shaft, but I need to freeze these and try the materials testing all over again.  If the temp affects the elasticity, then I’ll have to find a different solution.

Well, the diaphragm prototypes were all basically a bust.  They all had some kind of odd dimpling that was a result of the flexible printing process.  Bummer.  I talked to the manufacturing staff and we think we might have a solution.  I hate to have to send out for another batch cuz they are just so darn expensive, but if I remodel it, I think we can make it work.

Even with the dimpling though, I was able to install one of the thicker test diaphragms and see if it held against the vacuum pump.  IT DID!  That was pretty cool.  Now I just need to get the second round of flexible plastic prototypes and reinsert them into the plastic VRV cap and calibrate if for 5-7 in-hg.  Almost there!

Lots more to go, but seeing the light at the end of the tunnel here.  If I can get my suppliers to reign in the tolerance issues, and get my models refined, this could be a good Autumn.

Update 10/14/18:

I’ve been remodeling the 3D Model to compensate for the different tolerances for each plastic type.  Due to the parametric modeling, it’s slower than typical modeling, but it will allow me to adjust the tolerances with a simple click of a parameter.

The latest round of prototypes have allowed me to figure out the proper diaphragm orientation to remove the stipulation from the mating surface.  Now I need to improve the cap housing 3D model to adjust the interior routing of the channels.  Sadly, the channels do not always come back from the supplier with a clear tube.  Either I need to increase the tubing radius (that would exceed the design spec), or I have to post-drill these caps one-at-a-time on my press.  Ideally, I want to eliminate any human postprocessing when I get these from the supplier, but it’s looking like I have to consider that option if I want these made for a reasonable sale price.  If in the end, I order a thousand of these, maybe it wouldn’t be the worst thing to post-drill these in a premade jig in a day or so.  I don’t know.  Just a little discouraged by the claims of these suppliers and their quality assurance/quality control.

I’ll keep on working on these designs.

Potential Sale Items (as of Oct 13):

For the time being, I am gradually becoming prepared to sell portions of the VRV to people willing to give my prototypes a shot.  What that means:  I can sell you (for a reduced rate, e.g. at cost) these parts of the VRV:

  • Main housing
  • Housing cover
  • Cam Link
  • Cam
  • Castle Nut

So, if for example, you cracked the main housing flanges overtightening it to the IP, I could sell you this main housing.  You would have to transfer the old VRV parts over to the new housing, but this could fix your problem.  Also, for a minor fee (email me to determine the price), I could rebuild your VRV if you ship it to me.  I would need to examine the piece to figure this all out.

If you decide to join in this prototyping project, you’ll need to sign a waiver.  If you send your VRV to me to rebuild, I’ll be sure to return all your original parts.  If in the event you don’t like my prototype, you can revert back to the original parts.  Considering that Ford has no plans to restart selling these VRV’s, I think you’ve got not much to lose.  Best case: it fixes your VRV; Worst case: the replacement part doesn’t regulate the vacuum pressure, and are back to where you were.

What I still don’t have ready for sale yet:

  • Cap
  • Diaphragm
  • Springs
  • Housing cover hex-screws
  • Complete, bolt-on, ready-to-go VRV Replacement Assemblies

I’m still looking for a spring manufacturer that would take a small order (like 500 or 1000) for this project.  If you know anyone that can handle this project, especially someone based in the USA, please message me ASAP.  I have all the drawings and specs done, I just need someone to give me a reasonable quote.

Onward!

 

 

genscripter

24 Comments

Tow'n'Go

I’d love to chat via email

My 6.9 IDI has a working VRV and I’d be interested in helping you out. I’m up for paying for one now and testing out prototypes on my tow truck as this is a big problem for IDI owners

I was building my own solution, using a TPS, Line pressure sensor on the case, and a service to actuate the normal modulator connection and had an Arduino controlling it so it was using tps to determine the requested line pressure, then verifying it against the pressure sensor and could adjust for abnormalities very quickly. I may be done with it soon but it’s pricey

I like your approach as well

Reply
genscripter

I was thinking of arduino style controls as well, because I plan to redo my instrument cluster with a tablet, and use a variety of sensor and controls and relays to power stuff. I figured if the VRV ever went, I could so a similar method as you said with the tablet and arduino and some pc-controls stuff. But my VRV project is going to be a part-for-part supplier for people who want to replace their faulty VRV’s. I’ll email you soon once I get back on schedule.

Reply
Tow'n'Go

So, if you are looking for better plastics, may I suggest PPE or PPE+PS, that’s what I use for high end industrial applications, very very strong

genscripter

Thanks for the info. Everything I’ve read about PPE says that it’s still in its 3D-Printing infancy. Which basically means, the manufacturers aren’t ready for primetime, or the print prices are still too high. I gotta find a way to make these affordable to the customer, so that’s tough to accomplish with a PPE print process. I once got a quote from an industrial 3d-printing company that could provide VRV housings around $4000 per print. Yowza! I doubt people would spend over 4-big-ones for a VRV for an old IDI.

Tow'n'Go

That’s highly unfortunate, I wasn’t sure if you could opt for injection molding or a different process, I’m used to getting PPE since it has crazy strength, can you use another plastic or are your options very limited?

Could some vrv parts be machined with aluminum?

genscripter

I’ve been looking into aluminum casting and aluminum 3D printing. Both are expensive, but not as bad as you think. Both have some problems though. The casting is hard to get the finish and surfaces needed for the cam and camlink to operate properly. The 3d print is not that acceptable due to the abrasiveness of the finish. I suspect that after a few thousand miles of driving, the cam link would erode down to nothing due to the abrasive nature of the parts grinding together. I could cast some aluminum, then use a CNC mill to carve out the housing to make a smooth finish cavity for the the cam and cam link, but that would mean high fabrication costs or I would have to invest in a industrial rated CNC 3-axis router, both paths I don’t want to attempt at this stage. But yeah, I want to make an aluminum option VRV, that would cost approximately $400-500, but in theory, it should last forever, assuming I can get all the surface issues ironed out.

Tow'n'Go

I understand. I have a much much higher end printer at my Fab location and still can have the issues you experienced in your tests, but possibly not as much. The springs are still going to be the troubling part. It’s opt to re use the springs from the original vrv

genscripter

Reusing is possible, but I wanted to buy an inventory of new springs. So far, every spring manufacturer has rejected or returned a way-too-high price quote for my purposes. I need a small spring shop that can accommodate me. These big manufacturers just don’t see the value in doing 1000 VRV springs.

I have already modeled and drafted up the specs for the springs, so my papers are ready to go. All I need is a decent quote and I’m ready to go.

Tow'n'Go

I understand, I don’t know of many spring shops so that’s out of the question. I’m highly interested in getting this rolling since this possibly will be the end of many of my 6.9 turbo tow trucks. The Springs do appear to wear so reusing them may not be such a good idea, I’m running out of ideas how to fix this issue, unless someone(I’m looking into it) is to completely redesign the VRV with more modern and easily obtainable parts. I plan to toy with making modern vrvs using off the self parts as much as possible at the fab soon.

What plastic do you think you are going to try next?

genscripter

I’m working on a new VRV design. It would use less parts and just make a lot more sense than the current design. But I gotta get this inventory fixed before I move to that. And these plastics…. IDK. I think people give 3D printing a lot more credit than it deserves. The resolution on these prints are kind of pathetic. The holes I design can vary as much as hundredths of inches. Some holes come blocked up from the printer, some are way too big. I got to find something with better consistency. Also, most of these prints are not air or water tight…. Very porous. I’ll keep on working on this.

And I’ll keep on searching for spring companies. Gotta find a small-type manufacturer that won’t overlook my order.

Tow'n'Go

You experience the true issues of 3d printing. The biggest issue is big printing companies haul when the print these things. You end up with issue like the ones you describe. You need a much slower rate of printing which most people won’t do because it can tie up a printer for over 12 hours to print the parts you need. I could always try to print them on my dimension if it still works correctly. But I still highly suggest injection molding, it maybe be a much better option. Otherwise they would be better off being CNC’ed.

I would have to take a look better at it. My other concern is 3d printed plastic DOES NOT have a high temperature tolerance, worrying that on IDI’s in rough service this may allow fatigue and or failure!!! I do not want this project to fail as this is becoming a major issue for the IDI crowd, and I’m on my last VRV for my tow trucks.

Consider contacting other Fab’s like Protolabs or something. Otherwise you’ll need a state of the art 3D printer that uses disolvable waste material(kinda like my Dimension 1200)

genscripter

Yep, you’ve pretty much summed up my concerns. I don’t want to put out a product that will have temp and abrasion issues. Also, metal fatigue issues. I’m doing my best to find a plan.

I’m getting to the point where I can buy my own printer. Over time, it might be cheaper. Plus then I can get the resolution down to my spec. I don’t care if my printer takes 12 hours to print, cuz it’s on my time. Plus, I can load up the bay with many housings, cams, links, covers, and whatnot, to save space.

I’d love to do injection molding, but the prices are outrageous. Plus, orders start at 10,000 quantities and I’m not ready for that kind of investment. Plus, it costs a bunch up front to set up the dies. I’m looking into other material options instead of just plastic printing that might work, and have the durability I need.

Tow'n'Go

Awesome. I can give you suggestions on printers if you end up needing it. There are cheap junk out there and also very nice printers out there, you’ll be out about 20-50$ in material per VRV so you know.

Mary Raymond

I need a replacement vrv and would like to be notified when these become available.

Reply
genscripter

I’m still working on this project. I’m still doing plastic materials testing. The problem I have is finding a plastic that holds up to the stress and fatigue that a typical IDI can put upon it. But I’m working as fast as I can. I too want to have replacement VRV’s for my IDI’s, so I’m very motivated to get this project in a viable situation.

What part your your VRV failed? Maybe I have part of the VRV assembly that could work for you?

Reply
Eric Day

Please let me know when these are available as I am very interestd

Reply
genscripter

I’m still waiting for the third round of plastic prototypes to be fabricated.

Reply
John Duval

good job are there any available I need one pretty bad for my 7.3 idi

Reply
genscripter

It’s not ready yet. However, tell me what is wrong with yours? I might have a solution. Did you break the housing or cam-link? If yes, I might be able to sell you a replacement part. However, if your diaphragm is busted, then I don’t have the plastic prototyping done refined enough yet.

Reply
Zechariah

Do you have a timeline at this point before they might be ready? I’ve been having transmission issues for quite some time and believe this would be a fix. I have yet to attempt an adjustment, disassembly or anything to it.

Reply
genscripter

I still don’t have a complete VRV replacement yet. But I am beginning to start selling replacement parts of the VRV. I posted the available components above. As for adjustment, you should definitely adjust your VRV, both by rotating on the IP and by adjusting your castle nut. Just remember, be VERY CAREFUL adjusting your castle nut. Both the nut and the spring and diaphragm are very delicate, so proceed with caution. Never use massive force with these parts.

Reply
genscripter

More importantly, what specifically is happening to the transmission? Maybe I can help?

Reply
Harrison Baycroft

Hi there I am interested in buying some parts from you to fix my IDI.
-Harrison

Reply
genscripter

Which parts are you looking for? Do you need a whole new VRV, or are you looking for replacement parts of the VRV?

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *